Gadgets & Workspaces · Story 2

Pennsylvania lawmaker seeks ‘visual indicator’ if smart glasses are recording

A Pennsylvania lawmaker has proposed a bill requiring smart glasses to display a visual indicator when recording. The legislation aims to address privacy concerns around covert recording in public spaces.

This bill could set a precedent for regulating wearable cameras and balancing privacy rights with new technology. It also highlights the tension between technical workarounds and legal enforcement.

Key details

  • The proposed bill would mandate a visual indicator on smart glasses whenever they are recording.
  • Commenters note that some users already disable or cover existing LEDs, and forums provide guides for doing so.
  • The bill reportedly includes provisions to make disabling such indicators illegal.
  • The Reddit post about the bill received over 26,000 upvotes and more than 1,500 comments.
  • The discussion references existing laws in Japan and South Korea requiring mandatory shutter sounds on cameras.

Discussion angles

  • Users are already disabling or covering LEDs on smart glasses, with online guides readily available.
  • Some commenters support the bill but express concern about broader technology legislation infringing on privacy.
  • There is debate over whether making indicator disabling illegal would effectively deter the practice or just reduce incentives.
  • Several commenters question why similar transparency requirements aren't applied to other surveillance cameras like Flock systems.
  • Commenters point to mandatory shutter sound laws in Japan and South Korea as a potential model for universal standards.

Top comments

The community largely supports the idea of a visual indicator for privacy reasons but is skeptical about enforcement given existing workarounds. Many also call for consistent regulation across all recording devices, not just smart glasses.

People already cover/disable the LEDs on these glasses to hide current indicators. forums are full of how-to guides to disable the visual indicators.
u/madgoat · 2,594 score
I don’t have an issue with this at all, depending on the specifics of course. A lot of recent legislation around technology raises pretty significant privacy concerns, but I also think people being recorded in public without their knowledge is a pretty...
u/theclash06013 · 1,626 score
Correct, and like the 4th sentence in the article says the bill would prevent that. Making it illegal won't prevent the action completely but it would severely reduce the incentive to assist in the process.
u/BrutalBronze · 1,494 score
Neat. Now do the same thing for Flock and all the other cameras pointed at us in public places.
u/BeerInTheRear · 1,056 score
Japan and South Korea (and probably other countries) have laws where phones and digital cameras are required to make a shutter sound when a photo is taken. These kinds of features should be a universal standard IMO.
u/Ganrokh · 777 score